Language selection

Search


Notice of conclusion of administrative review: Small and Large Power Transformers (SLPT 2026 UP1)

Ottawa,

The Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) has concluded an administrative review concerning the normal values and export prices applicable to small and large power transformers originating in or exported from South Korea by Iljin Electric Co., Ltd. and of small power transformers originating in or exported from the Separate Customs Territory of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu (Chinese Taipei) by Shihlin Electric & Engineering Corporation.

In accordance with the Special Import Measures Act (SIMA), the administrative review is part of the CBSA’s enforcement of the Canadian International Trade Tribunal’s (CITT) finding and order issued on December 24, 2021 and December 20, 2023. For further information on administrative reviews, refer to Memorandum D14-1-8: Administrative Review Policy – Special Import Measures Act (SIMA).

The product definition and the applicable tariff classification numbers of the subject goods can be found on the CBSA’s Small Power Transformers: Measures in force and Large Power Transformers: Measures in force.

Period of investigation

The period of investigation (POI) and the profitability analysis period (PAP) for the administrative review is July 1, 2024 to December 31, 2025.

Administrative review process

At the initiation of the administrative review, the CBSA sent a dumping request for information (RFI) to exporters and importers to solicit information on the costs and selling prices of subject goods and like goods. The information was requested for purposes of updating the normal values and export prices for subject goods imported into Canada. Normal values determined on the basis of the administrative review will also be applied to any entries of subject goods under appeal.

As part of the administrative review, representations were provided by counsel representing parties to the proceeding, including exporters and producers. Details of the representations are provided in Appendix 1.

Details pertaining to the information submitted by the exporters and producers in response to the RFIs as well as the results of the CBSA’s administrative review are provided below.

Normal values and export prices

South Korea

Iljin Electric Co., Ltd.

Iljin Electric Co., Ltd. (Iljin Korea) is a producer and exporter of subject goods located in South Korea. Iljin Korea provided a response to the CBSA’s dumping RFI. A deficiency letter and supplemental RFIs were sent to Iljin Korea to gather additional information and to seek further clarifications. A verification was performed at Iljin Korea’s premises in South Korea.

Iljin Electric USA Inc. (Iljin USA) is a non-resident importer of small and large power transformers located in the United States of America. Iljin USA is considered to be related to Iljin Korea for purposes of SIMA.

Iljin Korea did not have sufficient domestic sales of like goods that complied with all the terms and conditions referred to in sections 15 and 16 of the SIMA as to permit a proper comparison with the sales of the goods to the importer in Canada. As such, normal values were determined pursuant to paragraph 19(b) of SIMA, based on the aggregate of the cost of production of the goods, a reasonable amount for administrative, selling and all other costs, and a reasonable amount for profits.

The cost of production was determined in accordance with paragraph 11(1)(a) of the Special Import Measures Regulations (SIMR), based on Iljin Korea’s cost data associated with the subject goods shipped to Canada. As Iljin Korea acquired inputs from associated suppliers, the CBSA investigated whether an adjustment should be made pursuant to paragraph 11.2(1) of the SIMR. The cost of the inputs was determined in accordance with subsection 11.2(1)(c)(i) of SIMR. The amount for SG&A was determined in accordance with subparagraph 11(1)(c)(ii) of the SIMR, based on Iljin Korea’s selling and administrative expenses incurred during the PAP.

For SPT, the reasonable amount for profits was determined in accordance with subparagraph 11(1)(b)(v) of SIMR, based on the weighted average profit made on profitable domestic sales of goods, that are of the group or range of goods that is next largest category sold during the PAP.

For LPT, the reasonable amount for profits was determined in accordance with subparagraph 11(1)(b)(ii) of SIMR, based on the weighted average profit made on profitable domestic sales of goods of the same general category sold during the PAP.

Based on the information provided, the CBSA was able to calculate the appropriate deductions accordingly to section 24 or section 25 of SIMA and conduct a reliability test of the export prices from Iljin Korea to Iljin USA. As export sales were also made on credit terms other than cash discounts, prices determined under section 24 and paragraph 25(1)(d) were also adjusted in accordance with subsection 27(2) of SIMA.

For small and large power transformers, the reliability tests revealed that the export prices determined in accordance with section 24 were unreliable and, therefore, the export prices for small and large power transformers exported to Canada by Iljin Korea through Iljin USA, for all future sales of small and large power transformers, will be determined in accordance with paragraph 25(1)(d) of SIMA.

As such, the CBSA established specific deductions to determine Iljin USA’s export prices based on its resale prices of the imported goods to unrelated purchasers in Canada, less deductions for all additional costs, charges and expenses incurred in preparing, shipping and exporting the goods to Canada, all costs, charges and expenses resulting from the imported goods, or arising from their shipment, that were incurred in reselling the goods in Canada (including general, selling, and administrative expenses, duties and taxes) or associated with the assembly and/or installation of the goods in Canada, and an amount representative of the industry profit pursuant paragraph 22(a) of SIMR. These specific export price adjustments are effective for small and large power transformers released on or after August 14, 2026.

Chinese Taipei

Shihlin Electric & Engineering Corporation

Shihlin Electric & Engineering Corporation (Shihlin) is a producer and exporter of subject goods located in Chinese Taipei. Shihlin provided a response to the CBSA’s dumping RFI. Supplemental RFIs were sent to Shihlin to gather additional information and to seek further clarifications. A verification was performed at Shihlin’s premises in Chinese Taipei.

Shihlin did not have sufficient domestic sales of like goods that complied with all the terms and conditions referred to in sections 15 and 16 of the SIMA as to permit a proper comparison with the sales of the goods to the importer in Canada. As such, normal values were determined pursuant to paragraph 19(b) of SIMA, based on the aggregate of the cost of production of the goods, a reasonable amount for administrative, selling and all other costs, and a reasonable amount for profits.

The cost of production was determined in accordance with paragraph 11(1)(a) of SIMR, based on Shihlin’s cost data associated with the subject goods shipped to Canada. The amount for SG&A was determined in accordance with subparagraph 11(1)(c)(ii) of the SIMR, based on Shihlin’s selling and administrative expenses incurred during the PAP.

The reasonable amount for profits was determined in accordance with subparagraph 11(1)(b)(ii) of SIMR, based on the weighted average profit made on profitable domestic sales of goods of the same general category sold during the PAP.

For subject goods exported to Canada by Shihlin during the POI, export prices were determined pursuant to section 24 of SIMA, based on the lesser of the exporter’s selling price and the importer’s purchase price, adjusted by deducting the costs, charges and expenses incurred in preparing the goods for shipment to Canada and resulting from the exportation and shipment of the goods. As export sales were also made on credit terms other than cash discounts, prices determined under section 24 were also adjusted in accordance with subsection 27(2) of SIMA.

Exporter responsibility

All parties are cautioned that, where there are increases in domestic prices and/or costs, the export price should be increased accordingly to ensure that any sale made to Canada is not only above the normal value but at or above selling prices and full costs and profit of the goods in the exporter’s domestic market. If exporters do not adjust export prices accordingly, retroactive assessments of anti-dumping duties may be warranted. Please refer to the Memorandum D14-1-8: Administrative Review Policy – Special Import Measures Act (SIMA) for details.

Importer responsibility

Importers are reminded that it is their responsibility to declare their anti-dumping duty liability. If importers are using the services of a customs broker to clear importations, the brokerage firm should be advised that the goods are subject to anti-dumping measures and be provided with sufficient information necessary to clear the shipments. To determine their liability for anti-dumping duty, importers should contact the exporters to obtain the applicable normal values. For further information on this matter, refer to Memorandum D14-1-2: Disclosure of Normal Values, Export Prices, and Amounts of Subsidy Established under the Special Import Measures Act.

The Customs Act (Act) applies, with any modifications that the circumstances require, with respect to the accounting and payment of anti-dumping and countervailing duties. As such, failure to pay the duties within the prescribed time will result in the application of the interest provisions of the Act.

Should the importer disagree with the determination made on any importation of goods, a request for re-determination may be filed. For more information on how to file a request for re-determination, please refer to the Guide for appealing a duty assessment.

Contact us

Email: trade_remedies_registry-registre_recours_commerciaux@cbsa-asfc.gc.ca

Appendix 1: Representations

Representations

Case arguments and reply submissions were received from counsel on behalf of Hitachi Energy Canada Inc., Northern Transformer Corporation, PTI Transformers Inc., PTI Transformers L.P. and Transformateurs Delta Star Inc. (collectively, the “Canadian producers”). Counsel on behalf of Iljin Korea and Shihlin also submitted case arguments and reply submissions.

During the course of the administrative review, counsel for the Canadian producers discussed various concerns pertaining to the responses to the requests for information (RFI) and supplemental RFIs.

There were a number of exporter and importer specific issues that were raised. In order to respect the confidentiality designations made by interested parties, the CBSA is limited in the information that can be divulged in response to arguments made concerning certain topics.

The non-confidential material issues raised by the parties are summarized as follows and the CBSA has provided a response below.

Credit adjustments

Representations

Counsel for the Canadian producers stated that, based on certain factors affecting the sale of the subject goods, the CBSA should apply present value adjustments to the sale price of goods in the domestic market as well as to the export price of subject goods pursuant to sections 21 and 27 of SIMA, respectively.

Counsel for Iljin disagreed with this approach for various reasons and stated that its sales are not made on credit terms. Counsel proposed that if the CBSA did make present value adjustments that it must do so both via sections 21 and 27 of SIMA rather than solely section 27.

In its reply brief, counsel for Shihlin agreed with counsel for the Canadian producers, stating that “Shihlin considers that both export and domestic prices should be discounted to present value as CBSA did in the original investigation.”

CBSA response

Based on the information provided, the CBSA determined that export sales were made on credit terms other than cash discounts. As such, export prices determined under section 24 and paragraph 25(1)(d) were adjusted in accordance with subsection 27(2) of SIMA. Furthermore, as domestic sales were made on credit terms other than cash discounts, the CBSA adjusted domestic selling prices in accordance with subsection 21(2) of SIMA.

Revenues

Representations

Counsel for the Canadian producers submitted that, with regard to the export price determination, the CBSA should remain consistent with the CITT’s decisions in Hyundai Canada Inc v President of the Canada Border Services Agency, (EA-2019-008/010) (Hyundai Canada) and Hyundai Heavy Industries (Canada) dba Remington Sales Co v President of the Canada Border Services Agency, (EA-2019-009) (Remington Sales), and disregard revenue associated with ancillary goods and services when they exceed the costs incurred. Counsel suggested that the CBSA should apply a revenue-capping approach used by the United States Department of Commerce. Counsel explained this method as when the costs associated with separately priced non-subject goods and services exceed the revenues from such non-subject goods and services, there is a net cost associated with selling the non-subject good that is necessary to deduct from the price of the subject good, in order to obtain an ex factory price of the subject good.

Counsel for Iljin Korea stated that there is no basis for the “revenue capping” approach suggested by the Canadian producers under the SIMA and must be rejected by the CBSA.

In its reply brief, counsel for Shihlin stated that “Shihlin understands that not including service revenues exceeding service costs is normal CBSA practice.”

CBSA response

The CBSA took the representations into account, and examined the revenues and expenses reported in the respondents’ submissions.

Based on the information provided, the CBSA established specific deductions to determine the export prices, for all additional costs, charges and expenses incurred in preparing, shipping and exporting the goods to Canada, and all costs, charges and expenses resulting from the imported goods, or arising from their shipment, that were incurred in reselling the goods in Canada (including GS&A, duties and taxes) or associated with the assembly and/or installation of the goods in Canada.

Accuracy and completeness of submissions

Representations

Counsel for the Canadian producers made representations regarding the accuracy and completeness of information submitted by Shihlin, in response to the dumping RFI and supplemental RFIs. Counsel submitted that the normal value and export price be determined pursuant to a ministerial specification.

Counsel for Shihlin responded to the complainant’s arguments, stating that the company provided all information required by the CBSA in order to calculate normal values and export prices.

CBSA response

Based on the CBSA’s review of the information submitted, the CBSA found that sufficient information had been furnished by Shihlin, and that the information was reliable. As a result, the CBSA used the information submitted by Shihlin to determine normal values and export prices.

Exclusion of related parties

Representations

Counsel for the Canadian producers noted that Iljin Korea’s domestic sales involved related parties, and argued that the CBSA should exclude all related parties in determining a reasonable amount for profits.

Consistent with the argument of the domestic producers, Iljin Korea stated that its profitability analysis set out in its case argument takes into account only sales to “unrelated” purchasers, excluding all sales to purchasers considered “related” by application of paragraph 2(3)(h) of the SIMA.

CBSA response

After reviewing the submissions on the record, related parties were removed in determining a reasonable amount for profit.

The CBSA should determine a single reasonable amount for profits for both small and large power transformers

Representations

Counsel for Iljin Korea argued that for the administrative review, it would be appropriate for the CBSA to define “goods of the same general category” to include both small and large power transformers and to determine a single amount for profit using Iljin Korea’s domestic sales of all power transformers in South Korea.

Counsel for the Canadian producers argued that the confidential record permits the CBSA to calculate separate profit amounts for small and large power transformers based on Iljin Korea’s own domestic sales and cost information and that the CBSA is not required to resort to a broader combined small and large power transformer profit pool.

CBSA response

For sales of small power transformers, the reasonable amount for profits was determined in accordance with subparagraph 11(1)(b)(v) of SIMR, based on the weighted average profit made on profitable domestic sales of goods, that are of the group or range of goods that is next largest category sold during the PAP. For small power transformers, the CBSA defined goods that are of the group or range of goods that is next largest category as domestic sales of large power transformers.

For sales of large power transformers, the reasonable amount for profits was determined in accordance with subparagraph 11(1)(b)(ii) of SIMR, based on the weighted average profit made on profitable domestic sales of goods of the same general category sold during the PAP. For large power transformers, the CBSA defined goods of the same general category as domestic sales of large power transformers.

Reliability and retroactive duties

Representations

Counsel for Iljin Korea and Iljin USA stated that the export prices should be determined under section 24 of SIMA as they are reliable based on the CBSA’s reliability test and the facts on the record relating to the export transactions at issue.

Counsel for the Canadian producers stated that the evidence on the record demonstrates that section 24 export prices between the respondents are not reliable. Counsel added that consequently, the CBSA should retroactively assess duties.

CBSA response

After reviewing the submissions, the CBSA was able to conduct the reliability test which revealed that the export prices determined in accordance with section 24 were unreliable and, therefore, the export prices for subject goods exported to Canada by Iljin Korea through Iljin USA, for all future sales of subject goods, will be determined in accordance with paragraph 25(1)(d) of SIMA. The normal values and export prices determined as a result of this administrative review may be applied retroactively where conditions are met. Please refer to the Memorandum D14-1-8: Administrative Review Policy – Special Import Measures Act (SIMA) for details.

Input purchase prices

Representations

Counsel for the Canadian producers stated that the CBSA should adjust certain input purchase prices in accordance with SIMR Subsection 11.2(1).

Counsel for Iljin Korea provided a confidential methodology for inputs acquired from an “Associated Person” under SIMR Subsection 11.2(1).

CBSA response

Where exporters purchased significant factor inputs from associated suppliers, the cost of the inputs were determined in accordance with subsection 11.2(1)(c)(i) of SIMR.

Page details

Date modified: